Mario's Bakery Menu (Update 2025)
Mario's Bakery, located in Oceanside, NY, offers a delightful array of baked goods with a focus on quality and taste. Notable dishes include the mouth-watering banana crème pie, scrumptious corn muffins, and delectable cannolis. Rave reviews highlight the bakery's attention to detail, freshness of their offerings, and friendly staff. Customers praise the diverse selection of sweets, including linzer tarts, sourdough bread, and wedding cakes that exceed expectations. The bakery's atmosphere is described as organized and clean, providing a pleasant experience for visitors. Mario's Bakery stands out for its commitment to using plastic-free packaging, making it a sustainable choice for eco-conscious customers. Whether you're picking up breakfast items like croissants and scones or indulging in a celebratory cake, Mario's Bakery is a must-visit destination for all your bakery needs.
Cakes
Strawberry Shortcake
in. EXTRA LAYER (-) servings yellow cake, strawberry filling and whipped cream frosting.
Strawberry French Cream
in. EXTRA LAYER (-) servings yellow cake, French cream filling, fresh strawberries on the outside and strawberry glaze.
Cannoli Cake
in. EXTRA LAYER (-) servings yellow cake, cannoli cream filling, whipped cream frosting.
Tiramisu Cake
inEXTRA LAYER (-) servings yellow cake w. cocoa, mascarpone cheese filling, whipped cream frosting, lady fingers around, cocoa powder on top.
Rainbow Cookie Cake
inEXTRA LAYER (-) servings tri color cake (yellow, red and green), raspberry filling, ganache on top and rainbow cookies around the sides. NOT NUT FREE
Small Leches
in (-) servings vanilla cake soaked in different types of milk (condensed, evaporated and heavy cream) with whipped cream frosting.
Large Leches
in.(-) servings vanilla cake soaked in different types of milk (condensed, evaporated and heavy cream) with whipped cream frosting.
Vanilla Fudge Cake
inEXTRA LAYER (-) servingsyellow cake, chocolate fudge filling and chocolate fudge frosting.
Chocolate Fudge Cake
in.EXTRA LAYER (-) servingschocolate fudge cake, chocolate fudge filling, chocolate fudge frosting.
Heavenly Chocolate Cake
in EXTRA LAYER chocolate cake, chocolate mousse, ganache on top.
Oreo Cake
in.EXTRA LAYER (-) servings chocolate cake, cookies & cream filling and cookies & cream frosting.
Layer
(-) servingsYellow cake, chocolate cake, chocolate mousse filling and chocolate fudge frosting.
All Vanilla Cake
in. EXTRA LAYER (-) servings yellow cake, vanilla buttercream filling and vanilla buttercream frosting.
Carrot Cake
in. (-) servings carrot cake, cream cheese filling, walnuts and raisins inside with cream cheese frosting. NOT NUT FREE
Red Velvet
in.(-) servingsred velvet cream cheese filling and cream cheese icing.
Crumb Bun
Small Apple Turnover
Large Apple Turnover
All Large Cookies
Elephant Ears
Raspberry Square
All Muffins
Croissant
Chocolate Croissant
Blueberry Scones
Fruit Danish
Cinnamon Buns
Fudge Brownie
Linzer Tart
Chocolate Cigars
Almond Horns
Cheese Danish
Mini Cupcakes
Vanilla and chocolate, of each.
Brownie Bites
Garlic Toast
Garlic Bread
Bagel Rounds
Bread Sticks
Large Cannoli
Breakfast Pastries
Rolls and Bread
Kaiser Rolls
Plain Club Roll
Sesame Club Roll
Dinner Rolls
rolls, mix of sesame, plain and poppy.
Ciabatta Rolls
Ciabatta Loaf
Plain Italian Loaves
cuts.
Seeded Italian Loaves
cuts.
Semolina Loaves
cuts.
French Seeded
Plain French
Large Round Italian
Sliceable, brick oven style, same dough as Italian loaf.
Small Round Italian
Sliceable, brick oven style, same dough as Italian loaf.
High Hat
Sliceable, for dip or soup carve it Italian dough.
Seeded Rye
Caraway seeds, sliceable.
Plain Rye
Sliceable.
Meat Bread
Ham, salami. garlic, black pepper. Also called prosciutto or lard bread.
Pumpernickel
Dark sliceable.
Sour Dough
Round, sliceable. For soup or dip.
Irish Soda Bread
Challah
Cinnamon Raisin
Garlic Bread
In tin bag.
White Bread
Sliceable, regular sandwich bread.
Whole Wheat Loaf
Small Italian Twist
Large Italian Twist
Extra Seeded Italian Loaf
Specialty Bread
Cupcakes and Cheesecakes
Cupcakes
Choose a type.
Red Velvet Cupcake
Plain Cheesecake
Chocolate Cheesecake
Chocolate marble
Fruit Cheesecake
Strawberry, blueberry and pineapple.
Italian Cheesecake
With dried fruits.
Apple Crumb Cake
Mini Cakes
Pound Cakes
Choose a type
Flan Slice
Tres Leches Slice
Chocolate Cake Slice
Strawberry Cheesecake
Lb. Italian Cookies
lb. Assorted Italian cookies.
. Lb. Italian Platter
Pignoli
lb. of pignoli cookies.
Hazelnut Biscotti
lb. Choose a type.
lb. Of Butter Cookies
lb. assorted butter cookies.
Lb. Butter Cookie Platter
lb. assorted butter cookies.
Rugelach
lb. choose a type
Rainbow Cookies
lb.
Black And White Cookie
Mini Black & Whites Cookies
Cookies
Mini Pastries
All Mini Pastries
Each.
Lobster Tails
Creme Brulee (GLUTEN FREE)
Mini Cheesecake
Sfogliatella
Mini Vanilla Cannoli
Mini Chocolate Cannoli
Mini Pies
Choose one.
Mini Lemon Meringue Pie
Apple Pie
Cherry Pie
Blueberry Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Pecan Pie
Coconut Custard Pie
Pies
Sugar Free Items
Sugar Free Pound Cake
Sugar Free Apple Turn Over
Sugar Free Mini Apple Pie
Lbs. Sugar Free Cookies
Sugar Free Sfogliatella
Each.
Pignoli Cookies (GLUTEN FREE)
lb.
Creme Brulee
(GLUTEN FREE)
Flan
(GLUTEN FREE)
Almond Horns
(GLUTEN FREE)
Gluten Free Items
Others
Walnut Ring
Black & White Cakes
Square Crumb Cake Tin
Marble or Plain
Plain Crumb Ring
Marble Crumb Ring
Babka
Philly Fluff
Apple Logs
Cheese Horn
with crumbs.
Melt Away
Pineapple Upside Down
Rice Crispy Treats
Chocolate Covered Rainbow Cookie
Cake Pops
Vanilla cake inside, chocolate on the outside.
Chocolate Numbers
Mini Vanilla Cakes Dipped In Chocolate
Chocolate Covered Oreos
pc.
Breadsticks
Pack of sesame seed breadsticks.
Fruit Tart
French cream with strawberries, blueberries,peaches
Numbered Candles
Choose a number.
Gold Candle
Silver Candle
Numbered Balloon Cake Toppers
Choose a number.